Page 1 of 1
fair use policy MP3 ?
Posted: 04 Apr 2009, 17:16
by yiannnisb
Hi!
anyone know if is legal to upload music mp3s to X2?
is inside in logic of fair use or not? (if my site is not commercial?)
thanks...
Posted: 04 Apr 2009, 18:06
by carter2
I don't think it's illegal to upload the mp3s to your web server it's when you let others listen to them, ie: sharing. It also depends on the license attached to the mp3's.
Anyway I think you have opened one of these
Posted: 05 Apr 2009, 03:37
by anytime732
technicaly speaking you shouldnt really publish anyone elses work without their consent. however since its not for comercial puproses the only thing that can be done is for he author or produsing company to request that you rmove the matetial from you site.
thats my understanding, though cater is right................big old tin of worms
Posted: 05 Apr 2009, 07:40
by carter2
There is an interesting discussion
>>HERE<<. Might help you a little. It's an old topic and things have moved on since then but it's still a good reference.
I personally use music that I have permission to use, what I mean is the artists have given me permission to use their music on my site.
Posted: 08 Apr 2009, 23:41
by mjau-mjau
Certainly an interesting topic, and I think it's a "greyzone" issue without clear definitions. I also think there is a huge difference in using commercial mp3 tracks on private sites, and for commercial sites.
Technically speaking, I don't think you are allowed to use mp3 tracks from a commercial artist, unless it is less than 6 seconds(or something). Then again, there are several artists I think(f.ex. Rà¶yksopp, Moby, Radiohead) who have free rights usage of their music.
My general opinion is that you should be careful if your gallery is commercial(for example professional products, company gallery etc). If the gallery is only for private photos(no commerce involved), I think the worst thing that can happen, is that you will be asked to take down the music ... And I think that will never happen anyway.
I think the people who "care" have much bigger problems with music being shared freely for download these days, than to care about a site that plays a track to complement a gallery.
Just my 10 cents, as I am certainly no expert!